Manchin in the Middle: Is He a ‘No,’ or a ‘Not Yet’?

Sign up here to get On Politics successful your inbox connected Tuesdays and Thursdays.

For months, it has been 1 of the biggest questions successful Washington: What does Senator Joe Manchin want?

Mr. Manchin, a West Virginia Democrat, fashions himself arsenic an old-school centrist dealmaker, the benignant of astir extinct legislature taxon who hashes retired deals implicit the bootleg moonshine helium keeps stocked successful unmarked Mason jars successful his Senate office.

Like astir each different senators who archetypal served arsenic a governor, helium often bemoans the information that he’s nary longer a main executive, with a information item and the quality to marque things hap connected command. He created a erstwhile governors’ caucus successful the Senate for like-minded colleagues and has often said his champion time arsenic a legislator was worse than his worst time arsenic governor.

Mr. Manchin, who was a backmost astatine West Virginia University earlier injuries derailed his diversion career, enjoys the nationalist spotlight and seeming nonstop attraction from reporters, chap senators and presidents excessively overmuch to person sought a instrumentality to the Statehouse successful Charleston.

The operation of his tendency to marque deals, make enactment and stay the halfway of governmental attraction culminated implicit the play erstwhile helium shocked Democrats, the White House and journalists with his announcement — connected “Fox News Sunday” — that helium would not enactment President Biden’s societal argumentation agenda, a $2.2 trillion spending measure known arsenic the Build Back Better Act that has served arsenic the superior conveyance for his party’s docket for 2021 and 2022.

Like his centrist Democratic workfellow Kyrsten Sinema, who has besides built a cautiously crafted representation arsenic a legislator who wants to get things done, Mr. Manchin finds himself astatine the halfway of competing priorities. He is the superior roadblock to the centerpiece of Biden’s home agenda, but arsenic the deciding ballot successful a 50-50 Senate helium is besides the cardinal fig with the powerfulness to make action.

As agelong arsenic that’s the case, an unending cascade of attraction volition travel from the White House, chap legislature negotiators and reporters, who for weeks person trailed Mr. Manchin astir the Capitol similar a battalion of bare dogs.

To fig retired whether Mr. Manchin’s “no” is truly a “no,” or, arsenic is often the lawsuit successful Washington, a “not yet,” I called Jonathan Kott, who worked arsenic Mr. Manchin’s conduit to the quality media from 2012 to 2019 and is present a lobbyist deciphering the senator’s thoughts for firm clients.

“Joe Manchin is ever up for discussing ways to get to ‘yes’ and however to marque a measure better,” Mr. Kott told me. “It’s who helium is. He’s a politician astatine heart. It’s however helium negotiated with the State Legislature successful West Virginia. I don’t cognize what the presumption of this measure is, but I cognize that Joe Manchin is ever unfastened to negotiations successful honorable and straightforward ways.”

So what, I asked, does that mean for the presumption of the Build Back Better legislation? What would Mr. Manchin hold to?

“He has told everybody what helium wants,” Mr. Kott said. “Joe Manchin is beauteous upfront and honorable astir what helium wants, and he’s been saying it for six months.”

Indeed, dissimilar Ms. Sinema, who went soundless before taking a public triumph lap aft Mr. Biden signed the infrastructure measure past month, Mr. Manchin is simply a regular talker successful the Senate hallways and a fixture connected the Sunday speech shows.

On Monday morning, he spent 15 minutes talking to Hoppy Kercheval, whose call-in vigor amusement successful West Virginia is possibly the champion gauge of the state’s politics.

There, Mr. Manchin lamented the precise nationalist unit run to get him to hold to the societal argumentation authorities and laid retired successful immoderate item wherefore helium remained opposed to it. He’s acrophobic astir the nationalist indebtedness and spending, the legislator said, and wants benefits similar the national kid taxation recognition targeted to the mediocre and the mediate class, alternatively than to each Americans.

(It is worthy noting that proponents of the taxation recognition for each accidental inserting an income headdress volition mean that the payment won’t spell to arsenic galore mediocre radical arsenic request it, and that enactment requirements would by their quality chopped retired millions of those successful poorness who could different beryllium helped.)

Biden’s ​​Social Policy and Climate Bill at a Glance

Mr. Manchin said that unit campaigns hadn’t worked connected him, and that helium wouldn’t alteration his mind.

“They figured, surely to God we tin determination 1 person, surely we tin badger and bushed 1 idiosyncratic up,” helium told Mr. Kercheval. “Surely we tin get capable protesters to marque that idiosyncratic uncomfortable capable that they’ll say, ‘Well, I’ll conscionable ballot for anything, conscionable quit.’ Well, conjecture what? I’m from West Virginia.”

So what’s next?

Both Senator Chuck Schumer, the Senate bulk leader, and Nancy Pelosi, the House speaker, offered a sunny outlook, saying that they didn’t judge negotiations with Mr. Manchin were over. The White House, contempt an bonzer connection connected Sunday that efficaciously called Mr. Manchin a liar, didn’t propulsion the plug, either. “Senator Manchin and I are going to get thing done,” Biden said Tuesday.

I asked Mr. Kott if determination was immoderate crushed to judge that determination could beryllium a aboriginal for Build Back Better. His reply seemed to beryllium 1 of acquisition — some for Democrats trying to recognize what Mr. Manchin wants and for Mr. Manchin himself, if helium does anticipation to beryllium the feline who tin marque a deal, and a large 1 astatine that.

“I don’t ever accidental thing is dormant successful Washington,” Mr. Kott said. “But erstwhile helium says, ‘I can’t spell location and I can’t explicate this to West Virginia,’ that’s a superior enactment from him. He means that.”

On Politics is besides disposable arsenic a newsletter. Sign up here to get it delivered to your inbox.

Is determination thing you deliberation we’re missing? Anything you privation to spot much of? We’d emotion to perceive from you. Email america astatine onpolitics@nytimes.com.